Capital Gains on Self-Generated Goodwill: Section 55 and the Machinery Provision
B.C. Srinivasa Setty, PNB Finance and the section 55 machinery: when a self-generated intangible escapes capital gains, and when it no longer does.
Sections 45, 48, 50D and 55 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, and their successors in the Income-tax Act, 2025
Consider a sweet shop that has traded from the same corner of a market town for forty years under the family name. Its ovens are old and its stock is modest, but customers queue on festival days because of the name over the door. The proprietor now sells the business. The buyer pays for the ovens, for the stock and for the tenancy, and then pays a further sum simply because the name and the queue come with the shop. That further sum is what the law calls goodwill.
Ask the obvious question and the difficulty appears at once. Capital gains tax is charged on the difference between what an owner receives for an asset and its cost of acquisition. What did this proprietor pay for the reputation of his shop? Nothing that anyone can point to. He paid for flour, for wages, for a signboard, for four decades of getting the sweets right. The reputation was not bought; it accumulated. The question of capital gains on self-generated goodwill arises precisely because the goodwill has value when sold, even though the proprietor may never have incurred any identifiable cost to acquire it. There is no purchase price and no identifiable date on which it came into existence. The issue, therefore, is whether the machinery of the Income-tax Act is capable of taxing the gain arising from its transfer at all.
The Machinery That Could Not Turn: B.C. Srinivasa Setty
The Supreme Court answered that question in CIT v. B.C. Srinivasa Setty [1981] 128 ITR 294 (SC). A firm was dissolved, its goodwill was valued at Rs. 1,50,000 on dissolution and taken over by a successor firm, and the Revenue sought to tax the resulting gain under section 45. The Court refused. Its reasoning was not that goodwill is not property – it accepted in terms that goodwill is an asset of the business – but that goodwill of a business commenced by the assessee himself is not an asset of the kind that section 45 contemplates. In a passage that has been quoted ever since, the Court observed that goodwill “comes silently into the world, unheralded and unproclaimed”, that it is “impossible to predicate the moment of its birth”, and that there can be no account in value of the factors which produce it.
The step that made this a general principle rather than a ruling about goodwill came next. Section 45 imposes the charge; section 48 prescribes how the gain is computed, by deducting the cost of acquisition and the cost of improvement from the full value of the consideration; section 55 supplies the meaning of those inputs. The central difficulty concerning the cost of acquisition of self-generated assets arises where no identifiable purchase price or acquisition expenditure exists. The Court held that “the charging section and the computation provisions together constitute an integrated code”. Where the computation provisions cannot be applied at all, the conclusion is not that the gain is taxed without deduction, but that the asset falls outside the charge altogether. This is what practitioners mean by a “machinery provision” argument: the levy fails not because the transaction is exempt, but because the statute has given the Revenue no instrument with which to measure it.
The Court also closed the escape route offered by section 55(3), which allows the fair market value on the date the asset became the property of the previous owner to stand in for an unascertainable cost. That subsection is of no assistance where the asset is self-generated: the date of acquisition by the previous owner is itself unknown, so there is no date on which any value can be taken. Srinivasa Setty was decided on 19 February 1981; a reader should note that the Court heard connected appeals from more than one High Court, so it is not to be described as the affirmance of a single decision below.
Parliament’s Answer: Deeming The Cost At Nil
A decision that removes an entire class of receipts from charge invites a legislative response, and it received one – in instalments. Beginning with the Finance Act, 1987, Parliament amended section 55(2)(a) to provide that in relation to specified intangibles the cost of acquisition is the purchase price where the asset was bought, and nil in any other case. Once the cost is deemed, the machinery works: the gain is simply the consideration, and capital gains arising from the transfer of self-generated goodwill become chargeable under section 45. The Supreme Court itself recorded the purpose of the exercise in CIT v. D.P. Sandu Bros. Chembur (P) Ltd. [2005] 273 ITR 1 (SC) at paragraphs 10 and 11, noting CBDT Circular No. 684 dated 10 June 1994 and observing that the amendment was made to meet the situation created by Srinivasa Setty, so that “the cost of acquisition would be taken as determinate but the rate would be nil”.
Because the amendments came in stages, the answer in any given case depends on the assessment year. The following table sets out the sequence.
| Effective from | What section 55(2)(a) brings within the deemed-cost rule | Amending Act |
|---|---|---|
| Up to AY 1987-88 | Nothing. No deeming provision; Srinivasa Setty operates at full width across every self-generated intangible. | – |
| AY 1988-89 | Goodwill of a business: purchase price if bought, otherwise nil. | Finance Act, 1987 |
| AY 1995-96 | Tenancy rights, stage carriage permits and loom hours added. | Finance Act, 1994 |
| AY 1998-99 | A right to manufacture, produce or process any article or thing added. | Finance Act, 1997 |
| AY 2002-03 | A trade mark or brand name associated with a business added. | Finance Act, 2001 |
| AY 2003-04 | A right to carry on any business added. | Finance Act, 2002 |
| AY 2021-22 | The words “or profession” carried through the clause; and where depreciation on purchased goodwill was obtained before AY 2021-22, that depreciation is reduced from the purchase price. | Finance Act, 2021 |
| AY 2024-25 | The residuary words “or any other intangible asset” and “or any other right” added. | Finance Act, 2023 |
Two entries are commonly misstated in commentary. The trade mark and brand name limb is the Finance Act, 2001 (AY 2002-03) and the right to carry on any business is the Finance Act, 2002 (AY 2003-04); the two are frequently transposed. And although the Finance Acts of 2020 and 2021 both took effect on 1 April 2021, they did different things – the former inserted the proviso to section 55(2)(b) capping the fair market value of land or building as on 1 April 2001 at the stamp duty value, the latter recast clause (a). The last row of the table matters most in practice. Since AY 2024-25, the residuary words “or any other intangible asset” and “or any other right” mean that it is very difficult indeed to identify a self-generated intangible whose cost is not now statutorily deemed. For current years, the Srinivasa Setty argument on cost of acquisition has, on any fair view, almost no field left to occupy.
Where The Argument Still Lives: The Undertaking Taken As A Whole
The deeming provisions attach to identified assets. They do not answer the different problem that arises when what is transferred is a business as a going concern for a single, undissected price, so that no part of the consideration is referable to any particular asset. That is the territory of PNB Finance Ltd. v. CIT [2008] 307 ITR 75 (SC). A banking company was nationalised and received compensation calculated by capitalising five years of profits. The undertaking included goodwill, tenancy rights, manpower and the value of the banking licence, and the compensation was not allocable item by item.
At paragraph 17 the Court framed three tests: that the charging and computation provisions are inextricably linked, so that failure of the latter defeats the former; an allocation or attribution test, asking whether the consideration was capable of being earmarked to individual assets; and the conceptual difference between an undertaking and the components of which it is made up. Applying these, it held at paragraph 18 that the gain could not be computed and was not taxable under section 45. One caution: the reported headnote on section 55(2) reads as though fair market value substitution was allowed, whereas the operative holding at paragraph 19 is that section 55(2) “did not operationalize” and was not applicable.
This line is older than PNB Finance. It descends from CIT v. Mugneeram Bangur & Co. (Land Department) [1965] 57 ITR 299 (SC), where a business sold as a going concern for a slump price yielded no figure attributable to stock-in-trade. It is refined by the pair of decisions delivered by the same Bench on the same day: in CIT v. Artex Manufacturing Co. [1997] 227 ITR 260 (SC) a valuer had itemised plant, machinery and dead stock, so the consideration was allocable and section 41(2) applied, whereas in CIT v. Electric Control Gear Mfg. Co. [1997] 227 ITR 278 (SC) there was no evidence of how the slump price had been arrived at, and it did not. The distinction is evidential, not conceptual: what matters is whether the record discloses an item-wise earmarking.
Here too Parliament legislated. Section 50B, inserted by the Finance Act, 1999 with effect from 1 April 2000, supplies a computation for slump sales by deeming the net worth of the undertaking to be its cost of acquisition and cost of improvement, “net worth” being defined without regard to revaluation. The Finance Act, 2021 went further, widening the definition of slump sale in section 2(42C) to a transfer “by any means” and amending section 50B(2) so that the fair market value of the undertaking on the date of transfer, computed in the prescribed manner, is deemed to be the full value of the consideration; Rule 11UAE, notified on 24 May 2021, prescribes that computation. For transfers on or after 1 April 2000, therefore, the machinery objection to taxing a slump sale is largely spent.
The Limiting Decision: How Easily The Argument Can Be Lost
It would be one-sided to present this doctrine as an assessee’s trump card, and the Supreme Court’s decision in Vatsala Shenoy v. Joint CIT (SC, Civil Appeal No. 1234 of 2012 and connected appeals, decided 18 October 2016) shows why. The Court there set out the PNB Finance reasoning at length, including the Srinivasa Setty passage on the integrated code, and then declined to apply it. Because separate valuations had been assigned to land, building and machinery, the transaction could be a slump sale “only if there was no value assigned to the individual assets and liabilities”; it was not, section 50B was not attracted, and, as the Court put it, a fortiori the judgment in PNB Finance also would not apply. Capital gains, including on goodwill taken at nil cost, were sustained. The lesson for both sides is that the machinery argument is won or lost on the documents. A valuation report that breaks the price down, a schedule to the agreement that allocates it, or a set of accounts that records the components separately will usually defeat it.
Consideration Is Not Cost: What Section 50D Does And Does Not Do
Section 50D, inserted by the Finance Act, 2012 with effect from 1 April 2013, provides that where the consideration received or accruing on the transfer of a capital asset is not ascertainable or cannot be determined, the fair market value of the asset on the date of transfer is deemed to be the full value of the consideration. It is sometimes offered as a complete answer to Srinivasa Setty. It is not, and the reason is structural: section 48 has two limbs, and the two failures are different. Srinivasa Setty fails on the cost side and on the date of acquisition; section 50D repairs only the consideration side. It does fill a real gap, answering a distinct line of cases of which Sunil Siddharthbhai v. CIT [1985] 156 ITR 509 (SC) is the best known: the contribution of a capital asset to a partnership firm was there held to be a transfer under section 2(47), but the credit to the partner’s capital account was of “a notional character” and the consideration indeterminate, so no gain was chargeable. That is a section 50D problem, not a section 55 problem.
If Not Section 45, Then Not At All – And The Qualification
A natural response by an assessing officer to a receipt that escapes section 45 is to bring it to tax under the residuary head. The courts have closed that door. In Cadell Wvg. Mill Co. (P.) Ltd. v. CIT [2001] 249 ITR 265 (Bom), a sum received for vacating premises held under an expired lease was held not to be a casual and non-recurring receipt under section 10(3) merely because it was not chargeable as a capital gain, and not to fall under section 56 either. The Supreme Court took the same view in D.P. Sandu Bros. at paragraphs 13 to 17, holding that the heads of income are mutually exclusive and that “if the income cannot be taxed under Section 45, it cannot be taxed at all”; it would be illogical, the Court said, to treat everything excluded from capital gains as taxable as a casual receipt.
The qualification is often overlooked. Sandu Bros. is not authority that tenancy rights are inherently incapable of a cost: at paragraph 12 the Court accepted the Revenue’s proposition in principle, that a tenancy right is acquired with reference to a particular date, may well be acquired at a cost, and that “it is ultimately a question of fact”, citing A.R. Krishnamurthy v. CIT [1989] 176 ITR 417 (SC). The assessee succeeded only because of the stand the Department had taken before the High Court. The same point emerges from the other direction in CIT v. Vijay Flexible Containers [1990] 186 ITR 693 (Bom), where the right to obtain a conveyance of immovable property was held to be property of any kind under section 2(14), and therefore a capital asset – with a cost, namely the earnest money of Rs. 17,500 actually paid. A right is not costless merely because it is intangible.
A Residual Argument, And The Case Against It
One argument has been canvassed in academic writing to the effect that the deeming of cost at nil does not fully cure the defect. The reasoning runs thus: sections 2(29AA) and 2(42A) classify a capital asset as long-term or short-term by reference to the period for which it was held; the period of holding of a self-generated intangible is as indeterminable as its cost once was; if the asset cannot be classified, the rate cannot be fixed; and on Govind Saran Ganga Saran v. CST, 1985 Supp SCC 205, uncertainty in any of the four components of a tax – taxable event, person, rate and measure – is fatal to the levy. The argument is developed by K.K. Chythanya, Senior Advocate, and Vipul V. Kamath in “The Ghost of B.C. Srinivasa Setty Is Not Yet Exorcised in India”, BCA Journal, February 2022. The counter is at least as strong: period of holding is fixed by reference to the period for which the asset was held by the assessee, and in the ordinary case a business has a commencement that the accounts and the registrations disclose, even if the reputation attaching to it accreted gradually. Parliament, having legislated repeatedly to defeat the machinery objection, can hardly be taken to have left the levy self-defeating; and no reported decision has yet accepted the period-of-holding version. It is an argument available to be run, not a settled position.
Under The Income-tax Act, 2025
The Income-tax Act, 2025 came into force on 1 April 2026 and recodifies rather than rewrites this area. The charge on capital gains, formerly section 45, is now section 67. The mode of computation, formerly section 48, is section 72. The previous-owner provisions of section 49 are carried into section 73. Section 50D becomes section 80. Section 55, which supplies the meanings of “adjusted”, “cost of improvement” and “cost of acquisition”, becomes section 90, and section 90 preserves the structure examined above: purchase price where the intangible was bought, the previous owner’s purchase price in the cases covered by section 73, and nil in any other case. Section 50B (slump sale) is understood to correspond to section 77. Readers should also note the change of vocabulary: the 2025 Act speaks of a “tax year” in place of the previous year and assessment year, so periods falling on or after 1 April 2026 should be described accordingly.
Because the deemed-cost architecture survives the recodification intact, the field left to Srinivasa Setty is not enlarged by the new Act, and the pre-2025 case law on that architecture remains directly relevant; a practitioner arguing a machinery point for a tax year under the 2025 Act will still be arguing Srinivasa Setty, PNB Finance and Vatsala Shenoy, translated into the new numbering.
Where The Doctrine Stands
Whether self-generated goodwill escapes capital gains depends on the year. For assessment years before the relevant amendment, and for genuine slump transfers before 1 April 2000, Srinivasa Setty and PNB Finance remain powerful and are regularly applied. For current years the position is nearly the reverse. Cost is deemed for every named intangible and, since AY 2024-25, for every unnamed one; consideration is deemed by section 50D where it is unascertainable and by section 50B read with Rule 11UAE where an undertaking is transferred; and Vatsala Shenoy shows how readily the argument is lost on the documents. What remains is a narrow but real class of cases – transfers of an undertaking as an indivisible whole where the record genuinely discloses no item-wise attribution, and older years still under assessment or appeal. In those cases the point is not technical pedantry. It goes to the existence of the charge itself, and, as Sandu Bros. confirms, if the charge under section 45 fails there is no residuary head waiting to catch what falls through.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Capital Gains on Self-Generated Goodwill Taxable When a Business Is Sold?
Yes. Since AY 1988-89, section 55(2)(a) has deemed the cost of acquisition of self-generated goodwill of a business to be nil. Consequently, the consideration attributable to such goodwill is generally chargeable to capital gains tax. Although Srinivasa Setty remains good law, its application to self-generated goodwill was effectively displaced by this legislative amendment.
Can a receipt that is not taxable as capital gains be taxed under Income from Other Sources?
No. CIT v. D.P. Sandu Bros. Chembur (P) Ltd. [2005] 273 ITR 1 (SC) holds that the heads of income are mutually exclusive and that if income cannot be taxed under section 45 it cannot be taxed at all. Cadell Wvg. Mill [2001] 249 ITR 265 (Bom) is to the same effect on section 10(3).
Does section 50D solve the Srinivasa Setty problem?
Not directly. Section 50D deems a fair market value where the consideration is unascertainable. Srinivasa Setty turns on the cost of acquisition and the date of acquisition, which section 50D does not touch. The cost-side answer is section 55(2)(a), and for undertakings, section 50B.
Sources & Citations
- CIT v. B.C. Srinivasa Setty [1981] 128 ITR 294 (SC) = [1981] 5 Taxman 1 (SC) = (1981) 2 SCC 460, decided 19.02.1981 (Tulzapurkar, Bhagwati and Pathak JJ).
- PNB Finance Ltd. v. CIT [2008] 307 ITR 75 (SC) = [2008] 175 Taxman 242 = [2008] 220 CTR 110, decided 06.11.2008 (Kapadia and B. Sudershan Reddy JJ) – paras 5, 15-19.
- CIT v. D.P. Sandu Bros. Chembur (P) Ltd. [2005] 273 ITR 1 (SC) = [2005] 142 Taxman 713 = (2005) 2 SCC 584, decided 31.01.2005 (Ruma Pal, Arijit Pasayat and C.K. Thakker JJ) – paras 10-12 and 13-17.
- Cadell Wvg. Mill Co. (P.) Ltd. v. CIT [2001] 249 ITR 265 (Bom) = [2001] 116 Taxman 77 (S.H. Kapadia and V.C. Daga JJ), approved in D.P. Sandu Bros. (above).
- CIT v. Mugneeram Bangur & Co. (Land Department) [1965] 57 ITR 299 (SC) = [1965] 3 SCR 611.
- CIT v. Artex Manufacturing Co. [1997] 227 ITR 260 (SC) = [1997] 93 Taxman 357; CIT v. Electric Control Gear Mfg. Co. [1997] 227 ITR 278 (SC) = [1997] 93 Taxman 384.
- Vatsala Shenoy v. Joint CIT, Supreme Court, Civil Appeal No. 1234 of 2012 and connected appeals, decided 18.10.2016 (A.K. Sikri and N.V. Ramana JJ) – paras 16-17 and 25-30.
- Sunil Siddharthbhai v. CIT [1985] 156 ITR 509 (SC) = [1985] 49 CTR 172.
- CIT v. Vijay Flexible Containers [1990] 186 ITR 693 (Bom) = [1990] 48 Taxman 86, decided 13.09.1989.
- A.R. Krishnamurthy v. CIT [1989] 176 ITR 417 (SC); Evans Fraser & Co. Ltd. (In Liquidation) v. CIT [1982] 137 ITR 493 (Bom) (a section 12B, 1922 Act, decision).
- Govind Saran Ganga Saran v. CST, 1985 Supp SCC 205.
- Income-tax Act, 1961: sections 45, 48, 49, 50B, 50D, 55(2)(a), 55(2)(b), 55(3) and 2(42C). Amending Acts: Finance Act, 1987 (w.e.f. 01.04.1988); Finance Act, 1994 (w.e.f. 01.04.1995); Finance Act, 1997 (w.e.f. 01.04.1998); Finance Act, 1999 (s.50B, w.e.f. 01.04.2000); Finance Act, 2001 (w.e.f. 01.04.2002); Finance Act, 2002 (w.e.f. 01.04.2003); Finance Act, 2012 (s.50D, w.e.f. 01.04.2013); Finance Act, 2017 (base date 01.04.2001, w.e.f. 01.04.2018); Finance Act, 2020 (proviso to s.55(2)(b), w.e.f. 01.04.2021); Finance Act, 2021 (Act 13 of 2021, w.e.f. 01.04.2021); Finance Act, 2023 (Act 8 of 2023, w.e.f. 01.04.2024).
- CBDT Circular No. 684 dated 10.06.1994; Rule 11UAE of the Income-tax Rules, 1962 (notified 24.05.2021).
- Income-tax Act, 2025 (in force 01.04.2026): sections 67, 72, 73, 77, 80 and 90, corresponding respectively to sections 45, 48, 49, 50B, 50D and 55 of the 1961 Act.
- K.K. Chythanya, Sr. Adv. and Vipul V. Kamath, “The Ghost of B.C. Srinivasa Setty Is Not Yet Exorcised in India”, BCA Journal, February 2022 (commentary, not authority).
Related Reading
- Is Goodwill an “Asset” for Depreciation? Smifs Securities and Explanation 3(b)
- Goodwill Removed from Depreciable Assets: The Finance Act 2021, Its Transition and Its Fallout
- The Cost-Step-Up Cap on Amalgamation: The Sixth Proviso to Section 32(1) and Explanation 7 to Section 43(1)
- Capital Gains for Individuals and Dissolved Firms: Indexation, Sections 176 and 189, and the Question of Whose Clock Counts
Whatsapp

